Welcome

... to our multi-player, multi-author, altogether unique and entirely free fantasy baseball commentary system! Register now to read all of the comments and add your own.

Without even registering, you can see a few players that we talk about. The salary scans are for standard 4x4 Rotisserie leagues. The three different bids are for the three most common leagues, explained in more detail in the Glossary.

Those who have come here from The Fantasy Baseball Guide 2012 looking for Stage Four are invited to click here. We hope you will register and then take over from that rude guy who has gone straight to Hudson News to ask for his money back.

Here are the last ten comments made by our members:

Gary Carter
ballfour
19 minutes ago
For a good example of old-time MVP myopia, look at Gary Carter's terrific 1982 season in context. He should have finished no worse than second or third in the voting, and you could have legitimately put him first. He finished 12th. Those were the days, my friends. tinyurl.com/6lln6pm

ballfour
31 minutes ago
Look at some of those games-played numbers. They really beat the crap out of the catchers in the old days.

He's right to have the M on the HOF plaque (I thought it was an ELB for my entire childhood, misguided as I was). Carter spent 12 years (and played 1503 games) with the Expos. He played five years (and played 600 games) with the Mets, and obviously he faded at the end of the NY stint.

Davey Johnson hit Carter fourth for most of the 1986 season, which explains the RBI count (Carter also had a .280/.373/.457 line with men on base, with more walks than strikeouts).

RIP, Kid. May we enjoy what we do even half as much as you did.
Jered Weaver
Alex
about 3 hours ago
I don't make projections because, the way I do it -- player by player, making educated guesses -- it's damn hard.

The question is, does my way get better results?

Overall, I'm sure it doesn't. Players do regress as a group and hence a system that emphasizes regression will do better case by case.

But do we care about the majority of players who cave in towards the middle?

Or do we care about the players who are on the edges, both directions?

The answer to that is clearly YES, so the next question is, can we identify them?

Second question being, can we identify them better with bids or projections?

Rotoman
about 3 hours ago
I think the usefulness of a projection comes first from the soundness of the baseline. Does it describe a player's skills and talents. This is the part that derives from the math looking at past history.

Alex doesn't make projections because he knows the type of projections he likes, those that take chances, are occasionally strikingly right and usually daftly wrong. That's the nature of predicting outliers. It's good fun, it's show biz, but it isn't going to help you pick winners consistently.
Gary Carter
LVW
about 4 hours ago
He was one of those players that you could be a fan of without being a fan of the team he was on.
Stage Four
SydThrift
about 4 hours ago
Rotoman, we followed your advice last year, almost, and went with a plateau keeper system 7 for 10th and 11th, 8 for 9th, 9 for 7th and everybody else gets 10.

Naturally, after I introduce the rule change last season, I finish last and am left trying to figure out which 7 out of 10 potential keepers to actually keep.
Gary Carter
SydThrift
about 4 hours ago
Supposedly said to Bill Robinson (86 Mets' 1B coach) "I'm not making the last f*cking out in the Wold Series" after he hit his game saving single.
Kid, you'll be missed. I still think the hat on your HOF plaque should be NY, not ELB or whatever that ugly Expos logo said.
Andruw Jones
JerseyJeff
about 4 hours ago
Youth is wasted on the young. Willie Mays played center field in the biggest space EVER in baseball history. They played polo in the Polo Grounds! And nothing fell anywhere in Mays' territory. Plus he had a gun for an arm, better than Andruw or any other centerfielder ever. I don't care what your eyes or statistics say, I Say Hey Willie Mays.
Jered Weaver
Alex
about 4 hours ago
There is indeed way more to talk about here. But the short version:

Peter thinks projections should regress, bids should take chances.

I think bids should regress, projections should take chances.
Gary Carter
Alex
about 4 hours ago
How did he drive in 100 runs in 1986? They must not have invented OPS yet.

To see all the players, literally thousands of players, and read the comments about them or add your own, you just need to register for free.

It's easy, it's quick, and it keeps away the bad guys. Once you have registered you will have access to all sorts of great search options, such as listing players by team, according to what they earned last year, or listing all catchers in the National League. There's a Most Recent Comments page and another that lists players according to the number of comments.

So take a look around, and if you like what you see, join the company!

About Us

1.562r29


You are viewing a mobilized version of this site...
View original page here

Mobilized by Mowser Mowser